If you’re buying or refinancing with an FHA loan, the appraisal is not just about value. FHA appraisers are required to assess property condition against a specific set of minimum property requirements — and items that would be noted but not flagged in a conventional appraisal can hold up an FHA closing entirely.
Understanding what FHA appraisers look for helps you prepare the property and avoid surprises that delay the transaction.
What Makes an FHA Appraisal Different
A conventional appraisal has one primary job: determine the market value of the property. The appraiser notes condition as it affects value, but most condition issues are adjustments to the final number rather than hard stops.
An FHA appraisal has two jobs: determine value and confirm that the property meets HUD’s Minimum Property Requirements (MPRs). If the property does not meet those requirements, the appraiser must flag the deficiencies, and the lender typically cannot close the loan until they are corrected.
This is not a home inspection. The FHA appraisal does not test systems the way an inspector does. It is a visual assessment of observable conditions that could affect health, safety, or structural soundness — the three pillars of HUD’s MPRs.
Who Can Complete an FHA Appraisal in Georgia?
Not every appraiser is eligible to complete FHA appraisals. HUD requires the appraiser to be on the FHA Roster, which is only available to certified residential appraisers and certified general appraisers. A licensed residential appraiser cannot complete an FHA appraisal.
Stephen MacDonald at Mac Valuations is on the FHA Roster and has completed FHA appraisals for lenders across Northwest Georgia.
What FHA Appraisers Look For
Health and Safety Items
These are the conditions most likely to hold up a closing. Common items include:
- Peeling or chipping paint on homes built before 1978 — a potential lead paint hazard that must be remediated before closing
- Missing or damaged handrails on stairs with four or more risers
- Broken windows or missing window glazing
- Exposed electrical wiring or visibly unsafe electrical panels
- Water intrusion — active leaks, significant staining, or evidence of ongoing moisture damage
- Roof condition — the roof must have at least two to three years of remaining useful life; significant damage or missing shingles will be flagged
- Inoperable HVAC systems — the heating system must be functional and capable of maintaining 50°F in all livable areas
- Missing or non-functional smoke detectors
Structural Soundness
The appraiser looks for evidence of foundation problems, significant settling, deteriorating structural components, or conditions that suggest the home is not safe to occupy. These do not need to be confirmed by a structural engineer — if the appraiser observes a condition that raises concern, it gets flagged.
Access and Marketability
FHA also requires that the property have safe pedestrian and vehicle access, that utilities be connected and operational, and that the property be habitable without significant repair.
What Happens When Items Are Flagged
When an FHA appraiser identifies a deficiency, they note it as a condition of value — meaning the value opinion is subject to the item being corrected. The lender will not close until:
- The repair is completed
- The appraiser or an authorized inspector re-inspects and confirms the correction
This is called a repair completion inspection or a desk review, depending on the lender’s process. Mac Valuations handles these re-inspections for appraisals we originally completed.
The practical implication for sellers: FHA buyers cannot waive these repairs. If the item is flagged, it must be fixed before closing regardless of what the purchase contract says.
Preparing a Property for an FHA Appraisal
The most common FHA repair flags are also among the most fixable. Before an FHA appraisal:
- Paint all peeling or chipping surfaces on a pre-1978 home, inside and out
- Install or repair handrails on any staircase with four or more steps
- Replace broken windows or repair damaged glazing
- Have the roof inspected if it is visibly worn — know what you’re walking into
- Confirm smoke detectors are present and functional in all required locations
- Address any active water intrusion — a wet basement or leaking roof is a flag
You can read more about condition factors in our post on What Hurts a Home Appraisal in Georgia?
What is the difference between an FHA appraisal and a conventional appraisal?
Both establish market value using the same comparable sales approach. The key difference is that an FHA appraisal also requires the appraiser to identify any health, safety, or habitability issues under HUD’s Minimum Property Requirements. Items like exposed wiring, missing handrails, roof damage, or inoperable systems must be noted and may need to be repaired before the loan can close.
Does the appraiser need to be FHA-approved?
Yes. FHA appraisals must be completed by an appraiser on the FHA Roster, which is maintained by HUD. Only certified residential and certified general appraisers are eligible for the roster. You cannot use a licensed-only appraiser for an FHA loan — the lender will not accept the report.
What happens if the FHA appraiser requires repairs?
Repairs flagged as required conditions must be completed and verified before the loan closes. The appraiser may return to confirm repairs (a re-inspection), or the lender may accept contractor receipts and photos for minor items. Required repairs are non-negotiable for FHA — the loan cannot close until HUD’s property standards are met.
How should I prepare my home for an FHA appraisal?
Focus on health and safety items first: ensure all utilities are on, all built-in appliances work, smoke detectors are present and functional, handrails are secure on stairs, and there is no evidence of active water intrusion or structural damage. Address exposed wiring, broken windows, and missing outlets. The appraiser is not a home inspector, but HUD requires them to flag these conditions.
Mac Valuations: FHA-Approved Appraisals Across Northwest Georgia
Mac Valuations is on the FHA Roster and serves lenders and homeowners across Bartow, Cherokee, Cobb, Floyd, Paulding, and surrounding counties. FHA appraisals are typically delivered within three to five business days.
Need to schedule? Call (770) 881-6049 or visit our mortgage lending appraisals page.
If you’re working with a certified appraiser matters for your FHA loan — read What Is a Certified Residential Appraiser and Why Does It Matter? for the full breakdown of credential levels and why only certified appraisers are eligible for the FHA Roster.